Showing posts with label Futures and Derivatives Regulation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Futures and Derivatives Regulation. Show all posts

Friday, April 17, 2009

Credit Default Swaps Making Corporate Reorganization Impossible?

The Financial Times reports that credit default swaps may be undermining companies’ attempts to reorganize in bankruptcy. When a debtor company attempts to reorganize, the success of the reorganization often depends on creditors agreeing to reduce, extend the repayment period of, or otherwise modify the outstanding debt owed to them by the reorganizing debtor. A creditor would be willing to do this because the modified debt would lead to a larger repayment than the amount the creditor would receive in the event of a liquidation of the debtor company.

Thus, corporate reorganizations are made possible because lenders have an interest in keeping their debtors from being liquidated. However, when lenders take out credit-default swaps on debtor companies as insurance on their loans, the lenders stands to receive full or partial payment of the debt from the CDS dealer if the debtor defaults. This payout from CDS increases the total return to the lender in a debtor’s liquidation; thus, lenders holding CDS-backed debt are less willing to accept reduced and/or extended payments from debtors, and corporate reorganizations become more difficult, if not impossible, to structure.

Should the bankruptcy law be modified to somehow fix this severing of a lender's and debtor's interests? Could a bankruptcy court revive a CDS-backed lender's incentive to compromise by modifying CDS contracts or by increasing the benefits of a reorganization? Or could the CDS dealer who inherits the lender's anti-liquidation interest somehow be brought into the equation?
Read More......

Thursday, February 26, 2009

SEC & CFTC May Get Bigger Budgets

According to The Wall Street Journal President Obama is asking for a 13 percent increase in the SEC's budget and a 44 percent increase for the CFTC.

This would put the SEC's budget at over $1 billion and the CFTC would be at $160 million. The administration hopes the SEC will use the additional funds to "pursue a risk-based, efficient regulatory structure that will better detect fraud and strengthen markets." With the money, the CFTC would increase staff, and would like to regulate credit derivatives.

I am not taking issue with the spending, but I am interested in knowing what the money would be better spent on. Should the SEC and the CFTC spend more on prosecuting violations, imposing additional rules, or some combination of the two?

Read More......

Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Major Changes Brewing for the Futures & Derivatives Markets

Jim Hamilton reports that the House Agricultural Committee has approved legislation that would dramatically alter the regulation of the futures and derivatives markets. The legislation includes numerous provisions, and a few are worth highlighting.

First, the bill would give the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) authority to initiate and conduct criminal litigation for violations of the Commodity Exchange Act if the US Attorney General has declined to bring criminal proceedings. Currently the CFTC and SEC only have the authority to initiate civil litigation for violations of their respective Acts, and can only recommend criminal proceedings to the DOJ. Thus, this expansion of the CFTC’s authority would give the agency a much more powerful presence in the futures and derivative markets.

Second, the bill would limit speculative position limit exemptions to “bona-fide hedgers” (i.e. those futures market participants seeking to hedge their price exposure to commodities stemming from production or consumption of those commodities). An important effect—and the probable aim—of this change would be that commodity swap dealers would no longer be exempt from position limits, and commodity index funds and other funds that enter the futures markets through these dealers would in turn be subjected to position limits. The imposition of these limits on commodity funds could potentially reverse the influx of investors into futures that has occurred in the last few years which many believe has led to “excessive speculation”, increased volatility, and artificially high prices.

Third, the bill contains a number of provisions geared towards reining in the unregulated credit default swap market. These provisions give the CFTC the authority to require mandatory clearing of CDSs at CFTC regulated exchanges and to temporarily ban both regular and “naked” CDSs under certain circumstances. While these and other provisions in the bill are still in very early stages, what is clear is that Congress will be very aggressive in pursuing major regulatory changes in the futures and derivatives markets, and we are likely to see equally aggressive legislation for the capital and banking markets in the near future.
Read More......

Friday, January 30, 2009

Clothing the "Naked" Swap Market


The Wall Street Journal is reporting a bill circulating in Congress that seeks to ban "naked" credit-default swaps.

Credit-default swaps (CDSs) are, in the simplest of terms, insurance contracts that insure the purchaser against corporate debt default. CDSs are sold by hedge funds, investment banks, and some insurance companies (AIG, for example), and thanks to a lack of regulation, these CDS-selling entities are not required to maintain a minimum capital level to support large-scale corporate defaults.

The CDS purchaser may want a CDS because the purchaser owns bonds or other corporate debt insured by the CDS. However, a "naked" CDS is a CDS purchased by someone that does not own the debt insured by the CDS; such a purchaser wants the CDS for speculative purposes and stands to make a profit if the debt issuer defaults. Likening the purchase of naked CDSs to taking out a fire insurance policy on your neighbor's home, critics claim that naked CDSs create unnecessary systematic risk by inflating the damage caused by corporate debt default and want naked CDSs to be banned completely. Opponents of such a ban claim that removing speculators will dry up the CDS market's liquidity, effectively making non-naked CDSs too expensive to be used as default insurance. Other proposals for dealing with the CDS market include imposing minimum capital requirements on CDS dealers and creating a central CDS clearinghouse, both to limit the counterparty risk of the CDSs.
Read More......

Wednesday, October 29, 2008

Greenspan's Grand Experiment

Way before the potential for a credit crisis was on anyone’s radar, American investment guru Warren Buffet dubbed derivatives, the complex financial contracts that are claimed to be the culprit of the collapse, “financial weapons of mass destruction.” Felix Rohatyn, a former U.S. ambassador and a central player in the 1975 plan that saved New York City from bankruptcy, described derivatives as potential “hydrogen bombs.”

One economic titan, however, felt differently. And as head of the world’s most influential economic institution, his views carried a lot of weight. I am talking about Alan Greenspan, Chairman of the Federal Reserve from 1987 to 2006. Greenspan had deep affection for deregulation. To him, the powerful financial institutions that (used to) populate Wall Street had a very large interest in ensuring that all of their assets were protected and that they had the resources in place to make sure all the investments they made were sound. While defending derivatives during a hearing in 2003, Greenspan said: “What we have found over the years in the marketplace is that derivatives have been an extraordinarily useful vehicle to transfer risk from those who shouldn’t be taking it to those who are willing to and are capable of doing so.”

In 2000, after years of pushing and shoving, Greenspan persuaded Congress to pass the Commodity Futures Modernization Act, the bill that removed derivatives from the purview of federal oversight. The derivatives market thereafter grew from $100 billion to more than $50 trillion. Although the housing collapse is often cited as the culprit of the current credit crisis, derivatives are what actually made our financial system vulnerable. Originally intended to reduce risk and spread prosperity, derivatives instead magnified the impact of bad mortgages. When homeowners began defaulting on their mortgages, the investment houses did not have enough capital to cover the derivative settlement claims and, as a result, are now in great peril.

In essence, the great debt that the world economy has to now face is the result of an experiment by Greenspan to let the market forces run free. Investment bankers, who collected billions of dollars in bonuses, were selling mortgage securities they thought were safe and derivatives that they thought would never have to be paid off. On the other side of the spectrum were the investors, who were buying credit default swaps that would pay off big when other people’s mortgage investments went south. And with the multitrillion-dollar market in place – no one was there to regulate. No one was keeping track of how many derivatives sold. No one knew who owned them. No one was making sure that the investment houses were setting aside the money needed to pay off their obligations if the mortgages went sour.

On Thursday, while testifying at a Congressional hearing, Greenspan admitted that he had “put too much faith in the self-correcting power of free markets and had failed to anticipate the self-destructive power of wanton mortgage lending.” Hailed three years ago as “the greatest central banker who ever lived,” the retired Chairman’s legacy will likely be quite the opposite: the man who paved the way to a global credit crisis.
Read More......

Monday, October 27, 2008

Credit Default Swaps: Part II

If you happened to read my last posting on credit default swaps, make sure to read the transcript from 60 Minutes last night, who aired another segment on the topic.
Read More......

Tuesday, October 7, 2008

Credit Default Swaps

For those who watched 60 Minutes’ segment Sunday on “credit default swaps,” were you enraged to hear about these financial explosive devices? Were you embarrassed to find out that our economy, the financial pioneer, has been taken advantage of by champagne drinking, shrimp cocktail eating Wall Street titans? I was, and I had trouble sleeping last night because of it!

If you did not catch this week’s edition of 60 Minutes, the show laid out the following horror story: Mortgage lenders sold loans with low introductory “teaser” interest rates. The lenders then sold the huge volume of loans to Wall Street banks, like Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers and Merrill Lynch, who then bundled them into bonds known as “mortgage backed securities.” To entice investors, the investment houses created and sold a “credit default swap” that was marketed to protect the investors against losses if the investments went bad.

And this is where it gets bad. In essence, a “credit default swap” is an insurance contract. However, the banks were very careful not to classify it as “insurance” and used a magic word, “swap,” as a substitute. If it were insurance, the person who sold the policy would have to have capital reserves able to pay in the case the insurance was called upon or triggered. But because it was a “swap,” and not insurance, there was no requirement that adequate capital reserves be put to the side. When homeowners began defaulting on their mortgages, and Wall Street's high-risk mortgage backed securities also began to fail, the big investment houses had not set aside the money they needed to pay off their obligations. And this is where we are today.

Thomas Friedman, the Pulitzer Prize author on foreign-affairs, says that there have only been a few times in his life when he has truly been frightened for this country: the Cuban missile crisis in 1962; when J.F.K was assassinated in 1963; on September 11, 2001; and today, the scariest moment of them all. While the first three attacks on the U.S. were by outsiders, today’s financial crisis was a result of our own failure to regulate our financial system. In other words: we let greed take over.

Look at us now. On Monday morning, the Fed announced that the system will receive yet another enormous injection of liquidity, saying it would make as much as $900 billion available. But what is especially frightening is that even with action of this magnitude, confidence does not seem to be restored. By Monday, the Dow dropped 370 points. European markets are falling. Russia and Brazil shut down trading. Not exactly confidence-boosters.

About one hundred years ago, in response to the creation of the Federal Reserve, Charles Lindbergh, a Congressman from Minnesota, made this comment: “From now on depressions will be scientifically created. Like two con men working a mark, the Fed made credit easy while…newspapers hyped what riches could be made in the stock market.” Well said Congressman Lindbergh. Nothing seems to have changed.

For a complete transcript from last Sunday's 60 Minutes, visit:
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2008/10/05/60minutes/main4502454.shtml
Read More......